Film: Brave (2012)
Jan. 15th, 2018 11:13 pmBrave, how I love thee, let me count the ways.
Too often, Disney films featuring female leads (generally a princess of some kind and in one way or another) revolve around reductive agency. Even with heroines coded as independent and with subplots that suggest a higher or greater purpose (i.e. Belle's pursuit of knowledge in Beauty and the Beast, Ariel's thirst for freedom and adventure in The Little Mermaid, or Pocahontas's desire to save her people) the story always winds up as a treatise on how Our Heroine gets a man in the end. Happily Ever After as it has been codified for women in Disney films means marriage, of course.
Culturally, American society likes to privilege romantic love over every other kind of love and nowhere do they showcase that preference better than in films. So, the first time that I saw Disney's Brave I was utterly thrilled and completely charmed. I fell in love with the essential relationship at the heart of the story, Merida and her mother, Eleanor. Like many Disney princess films, Brave is a love story. However, unlike the typical Disney princess films, it is not about romantic love, rather it is about familial love. A few years later, Frozen would do something similar and come under fire for it in the process, but let's not forget that Brave did it first.
In Brave we are shown the importance and intensity of familial love. Personally, I think that it's even more important that it's Mother/Daughter love. Too often that relationship is depicted as fraught an unforgiving. It plays into the stereotype of toxic and competitive women's relationships. An even though the relationship between Merida and Eleanor begins strained, over the course of the film they each learn to understand the other. There is never a question that they love each other, but it is the way that they learn to deal with each other and to LISTEN to each other that, I believe, is most important here. The result of that relationship rekindling is never demonstrated more beautifully that at the end of movie when Bear!Eleanor breaks free of her bonds and takes on Mor'du as he towers over Merida, roaring in preparation of the kill. It is telling, I think, and deeply appropriate that neither Merida's father nor any of the men of the clans are able to save Merida. It is Eleanor's job to do and the opening up of Merida's relationship with her mother has lead them there. Their conflict becomes overwhelmed by the action in that moment and the battle is beautifully representative of what has always been true, even when Eleanor and Merida could not see it for themselves: Eleanor's love for her daughter (and Merida's for her mother in the moment when she defends Bear!Eleanor from her father).
I love the battle between Eleanor and Mor'du because I am a sucker for Mother/Daughter relationships. And Eleanor, willing to sacrifice herself to save her daughter, is the epitome of the ultimate mother sacrifice. Merida's realization that perhaps she realized her mother's value much too late is equally impactful. But of course, this is a Disney film. But here happily ever after doesn't end with a man and a wedding gown, rather it ends with Merida and her mother having learned to understand and appreciate each other. Their love for each other is point and it is recognized and celebrated as the ultimate prize.
Too often, Disney films featuring female leads (generally a princess of some kind and in one way or another) revolve around reductive agency. Even with heroines coded as independent and with subplots that suggest a higher or greater purpose (i.e. Belle's pursuit of knowledge in Beauty and the Beast, Ariel's thirst for freedom and adventure in The Little Mermaid, or Pocahontas's desire to save her people) the story always winds up as a treatise on how Our Heroine gets a man in the end. Happily Ever After as it has been codified for women in Disney films means marriage, of course.
Culturally, American society likes to privilege romantic love over every other kind of love and nowhere do they showcase that preference better than in films. So, the first time that I saw Disney's Brave I was utterly thrilled and completely charmed. I fell in love with the essential relationship at the heart of the story, Merida and her mother, Eleanor. Like many Disney princess films, Brave is a love story. However, unlike the typical Disney princess films, it is not about romantic love, rather it is about familial love. A few years later, Frozen would do something similar and come under fire for it in the process, but let's not forget that Brave did it first.
In Brave we are shown the importance and intensity of familial love. Personally, I think that it's even more important that it's Mother/Daughter love. Too often that relationship is depicted as fraught an unforgiving. It plays into the stereotype of toxic and competitive women's relationships. An even though the relationship between Merida and Eleanor begins strained, over the course of the film they each learn to understand the other. There is never a question that they love each other, but it is the way that they learn to deal with each other and to LISTEN to each other that, I believe, is most important here. The result of that relationship rekindling is never demonstrated more beautifully that at the end of movie when Bear!Eleanor breaks free of her bonds and takes on Mor'du as he towers over Merida, roaring in preparation of the kill. It is telling, I think, and deeply appropriate that neither Merida's father nor any of the men of the clans are able to save Merida. It is Eleanor's job to do and the opening up of Merida's relationship with her mother has lead them there. Their conflict becomes overwhelmed by the action in that moment and the battle is beautifully representative of what has always been true, even when Eleanor and Merida could not see it for themselves: Eleanor's love for her daughter (and Merida's for her mother in the moment when she defends Bear!Eleanor from her father).
I love the battle between Eleanor and Mor'du because I am a sucker for Mother/Daughter relationships. And Eleanor, willing to sacrifice herself to save her daughter, is the epitome of the ultimate mother sacrifice. Merida's realization that perhaps she realized her mother's value much too late is equally impactful. But of course, this is a Disney film. But here happily ever after doesn't end with a man and a wedding gown, rather it ends with Merida and her mother having learned to understand and appreciate each other. Their love for each other is point and it is recognized and celebrated as the ultimate prize.